Moderation Feedback Thread |
Moderation Feedback Thread |
Apr 25 2008, 17:41
Post
#261
|
|
Gee, I wish we had one of them doomsday machines. Group: Moderators Posts: 2,037 Joined: 13-November 06 From: Wales Member No.: 155 |
Heh.
The image size limit on the BI forums is even worse. I hope they have fun ^^ (Still think it should have been upped to 200kb...) -------------------- The Rules - Nothing too complicated, follow these and we'll have no problems.
Moderation Feedback Thread - Tell everyone how much you Site Issues Thread - Complain about site issues here. We might even fix them! Community Chatter Thread - Furthest Mud-sling gets a free subscription to "JdB Monthly". QUOTE(Major Mike Shearer) We can categorically state that we have not released man-eating badgers into the area. QUOTE(Brace Belden) A machine gun is like a woman, I don’t understand it, I’m afraid of it, and one day I’ll accidentally be killed by one. |
|
|
Apr 25 2008, 19:08
Post
#262
|
|
Hipster addonmaker Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 2,090 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Kingdom of the Netherlands Member No.: 10 |
If anyone feels they can't live with rules being enforced, or the exact content of these rules, they're free to leave. Everyone agrees to adhere to the rules when they register. Personally I'm not too bothered about them leaving. At least 80% of the reports in the Moderators' private section of the last few months are about members of this mod violating rules repeatedly, fact-bending, flaming staff, making false accusations and offending people offering constructive criticism on their work. When at least 80% of the total time moderating is spent on keeping a single individual or group in line, that is telling. After several staff members have tried their best to reason with a group, both individually and as part of a larger discussion, with zero result except flaming, false accusations and continued violations, sometimes just moving on is the best idea. If this means we won't have to put up with these things, then the whole forum will be better off.
We already compromised for the increased broadband usage worldwide and ever increasing screen-size by raising the limit to 150kb, 100kb just being a relic of the 90's. Took away 85% of the file-size violations, although there are some repeat-offenders. The file size for images will be increased to 200kb. In about 5 years. -------------------- |
|
|
Apr 26 2008, 05:06
Post
#263
|
|
head in the stars Group: Members Posts: 549 Joined: 12-November 06 From: Bittany Member No.: 32 |
why they don't use thumbnails? it's easy and better in my opinion
-------------------- |
|
|
May 1 2008, 00:37
Post
#264
|
|
Gentleman Usher of the Coffee Stain Group: Site Team Posts: 677 Joined: 5-November 06 From: C18.3#C77.2#G63.1 Member No.: 19 |
Because they appear to be as stubborn as I am. It's funny though that an entire bunch of people shows this attitude as if they were one person.
-------------------- |
|
|
May 1 2008, 11:51
Post
#265
|
|
Hipster addonmaker Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 2,090 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Kingdom of the Netherlands Member No.: 10 |
I could send this to one person that did it this time, but since we get this increasingly often I will tell it to everyone:
The "Report" function is for serious problems only, not for deleting accidental double posts, or other mistakes you happen to make. -------------------- |
|
|
May 22 2008, 00:17
Post
#266
|
|
Group: Addon Maker Posts: 1,148 Joined: 4-November 06 Member No.: 13 |
Doomek, are you not seeing posts made by certain members? A repeat violation makes for another 12hr PR and a permanent warning block. Always list your addons. I don't know how do you do it, but I think it would be the best to send a private message to the PR'd member about their violation of the rules. Otherwise they might not notice that they have been PR'd / what did they do wrong, if they won't notice your post in the thread where you PR'd them or if they are away during that PR time... But if you already do send them private messages about the violation of the rules, then ok, I guess Doomek was kinda blind... |
|
|
May 22 2008, 00:44
Post
#267
|
|
Hipster addonmaker Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 2,090 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Kingdom of the Netherlands Member No.: 10 |
I don't know how do you do it, but I think it would be the best to send a private message to the PR'd member about their violation of the rules. Otherwise they might not notice that they have been PR'd / what did they do wrong, if they won't notice your post in the thread where you PR'd them or if they are away during that PR time... But if you already do send them private messages about the violation of the rules, then ok, I guess Doomek was kinda blind... I stopped sending PMs for anything that is mentioned explicitly at the start of a topic like the additional rules of several topics, or things that are common sense (the more straightforward rules like spam, flooding, warez), since A.) They're in plain sight B.) I would end up having to write and send dozens of PMs a month. Dealing with everything through PM adds the additional disadvantages that A.) People act like moderators by correcting others because they're not aware of the actions already taken by moderators, ending up in spam(ming a thread off-topic) B.) Do not serve as general reminders to anyone else. Like when someone posts warez I don't PM them to say that they're banned, I just write it in the topic. There is no point in contacting them personally since their "mistake" is so obvious(ly wrong). Doing this only attracts verbal abuse like most of my PMs in the last few months have with the really problematic cases that I sent to. One thing that is done through PM is signature violations, since it doesn't apply to any particular post unlike for example the not listing of addons, Deadeye tends to add a notice in the user's signature (I don't know if he also sends a PM). -------------------- |
|
|
May 22 2008, 10:09
Post
#268
|
|
ArmA.info Sarcasm Society's Gentleman Usher of the Banstick Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 1,781 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Old-Europe Member No.: 11 |
As you already said Rellikki the user does get a PM when a WB is added. I usually add the link to the topic and the reason why the PR/WB was handed out. As a new PM always pops up when you load the forum there's litterally no way of not getting informed about the breach of the rules.
For signature violation I hardly ever PM the person though. -------------------- |
|
|
May 25 2008, 21:57
Post
#269
|
|
The Il2 Fan Group: Members Posts: 733 Joined: 7-November 06 From: England Member No.: 25 |
i must be special because i got a pm of both of you about mine.
-------------------- |
|
|
Jun 8 2008, 15:36
Post
#270
|
|
Hipster addonmaker Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 2,090 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Kingdom of the Netherlands Member No.: 10 |
Unlike usual, the latest rules update wasn't announced when it was introduced (3 April 2008), but to counter all "I didn't know"s, some alterations were made to the rules after an extensive discussion (only rules that have been changed/added are shown):
QUOTE As it is impossible to plan for every possible situation, the moderators reserve the right to discuss extraordinary matters internally, and if necessary to take action against anyone that damages the integrity of the site, site team or moderating staff, even if there is no specific rule against what they have done/are doing. [§1] No discussion on game-alterations that break the EULA Discussions about copy protection or copying, backing-up, hacking, cracking or reverse engineering of BIS games, or any other software will not be tolerated. Such discussions may be deleted immediately. Any breach of this rule may result in the poster no longer having access to the site and forums. If the poster produces addons, the site-team may decide to have his/their addons banned from the site. [§6] No posting of explicit graphics No posting of videos, pictures and other types of graphical media containing porn, real killing, mutilations, wounds, carnage, and other disgusting/explicit images. This also includes links to pages that contain such content. There have been a number of incidents where people have linked to news sites which unbeknownst to them contains obscene images a few mouse clicks away, while we can't expect people to check every link on a site it is strongly suggested that whenever making a post about a news item the post is structured in a way that provides the information without risk of breaching the rules. If you're ever unsure as to whether or not a link should be posted on the forum feel free to PM a moderator for guidance. [§7] No usage of content of forbidden organisations This includes, but is not limited to organisations, symbols and propaganda messages of organizations like Nazi/neo-nazi parties, Hamas, Al-Qaeda, and other organizations that are on international lists of terrorist organizations, or forbidden by the European Union or any of it's member states. The European Union's list of forbidden people and organizations can be found [here]. [§9] No public discussion on how the forum is moderated If you have questions/complaints/comments that you wish to make about the board or moderators or anything like that please PM them to a moderator, we will do our utmost to reply to any that we receive, please remember we have lives outside of the forum so can't promise to reply immediately. There is also a dedicated thread located [here] for discussing the moderating policy, it is meant for the general policy, not for individual cases, that should be restricted to PM. [§11] No advertisement about non ArmA related stuff Do not use the forum to make direct or indirect advertisement concerning something not related to ArmA. Commercial ventures that are not licensed by BIS itself, or any other party that owns the content in question, and does not allow the poster to exploit it are not allowed either. [§12] No posting of VBS information ArmedAssault.info is dedicated to BIS games only so absolutely no discussion of VBS in any of its incarnations is allowed. [§13] No images are to be posted in the English section that exceed 150kb's filesize. You may be post restricted after your first warning for failure to comply with this rule. [§14] Images may not be made up of more than 1 file This rule is meant to ensure that §13 is successful in keeping the forum easy to access for all people regardless of their hardware. An image must be made of a single, continuous file. When more than one file is used, we will take action against the poster. [§4] Do not double, triple etc -post If you make several posts in a short amount of time rather than editing your original post, this will be considered flooding. After a first warning you may be post restricted for failure to comply with this rule. This does not include accidentaly posting multiple times through browser or server errors. [§8] Write in English As this is the English part of the board please write in English. Don't write in any other language since the majority of the members most likely won't understand. Posting in any language other than English and providing a translation in English is also not allowed, since we cannot check the accuracy of the translation. Changed Changed Changed Added Changed Changed Changed Changed Added Added Changed -------------------- |
|
|
Jul 1 2008, 22:08
Post
#271
|
|
The One and the Only! Group: Members Posts: 52 Joined: 12-November 06 From: Scotland Member No.: 35 |
LMAO. a thread got locked for being bumped for a short 2 months XD I would just like to point out that this silly forum is rly bizzare so I am leaving this dump for another 4 months (posted in here incase its mistaken for a moderation method or some crap like that ) laters all
-------------------- Is king homer cheeky?
|
|
|
Jul 3 2008, 11:04
Post
#272
|
|
ARCP Winner 2007 Group: Members Posts: 263 Joined: 12-November 06 From: Lake District, England Member No.: 100 |
Aye, this is one of those rare occasions where I agree with brataccas. Try not to be too trigger happy in locking posts, some people may have more to add. Surely adding to a thread of a certain topic is better than lots of locked/unlocked threads of similar subject.
-------------------- OFP/Arma addict turned forum lurker.
|
|
|
Jul 3 2008, 14:34
Post
#273
|
|
Hipster addonmaker Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 2,090 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Kingdom of the Netherlands Member No.: 10 |
Aye, this is one of those rare occasions where I agree with brataccas. Try not to be too trigger happy in locking posts, some people may have more to add. Surely adding to a thread of a certain topic is better than lots of locked/unlocked threads of similar subject. Brataccas has a warning level of 80%, which he didn't get for simply posting in a locked topic or similar (rather attacking moderating and site team on numerous occasions). I warned him not to violate any more rules, which he replied to that he forgot because he hadn't been on the forum in a while. Barely 30 minutes later he then posted in all capital letters in an old thread, adding nothing to the subject that was a valid reason to revive the thread. This shows that he simply doesn't respect the rules, or the people enforcing them. He had been told not to break any rules. As these two violations are both rules here, and Brataccas has shown not to be all that interested in staying here, he is hereby banned from the forums. He has had enough chances already, including the unique instance where he was unbanned, and being forgiven the creation of several duplicate accounts, to be given a last chance. I again gave him a last chance when I told him not to break any more rules. Our patience is not endless. I have discussed this with Helping Hand, and he didn't think it deserved a ban, but I have decided to overrule him, as he hasn't witnessed the amount of abuse that brataccas has produced, and the total lack of interest in following the rules. As mentioned in this topic, problems that have been resolved before in earlier topics do not need new topics, if someone is too lazy to search for the answer with the Search feature, then their thread is closed. Topics that have ceased to be of use, either because the problem has been resolved, or due to the age of the topic and lack of a valid reason for reviving, will also be closed. As said many times before, the Chatter, Word Games & Jokes section is meant for subjects that are not directly linked to BIS games or the military, but must have a sane subject, and must abide with the forum rules, and is not like what brataccas seems to think judging by some of the topics he created, a free-for-all. -------------------- |
|
|
Jul 4 2008, 03:02
Post
#274
|
|
Gentleman Usher of the Coffee Stain Group: Site Team Posts: 677 Joined: 5-November 06 From: C18.3#C77.2#G63.1 Member No.: 19 |
I'll miss his spammery, he was somewhat the Hawkeye Pierce of these forums.
-------------------- |
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 21:48
Post
#275
|
|
N00b always & everywhere Group: Members Posts: 430 Joined: 30-October 07 From: Wodzisław Śl. - Poland Member No.: 1,589 |
http://forum.armedassault.info/index.php?s...ost&p=46783
Yes, but also should be in Combat Photography IMHO. It's only a add notation. |
|
|
Jul 22 2008, 00:04
Post
#276
|
|
ArmA.info Sarcasm Society's Gentleman Usher of the Banstick Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 1,781 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Old-Europe Member No.: 11 |
http://forum.armedassault.info/index.php?s...ost&p=46783 Yes, but also should be in Combat Photography IMHO. It's only a add notation. QUOTE SaS TrooP, screenshots with information about the subject meant as a promotion for the mod should mainly be posted in the mod's thread, where it is most appropriate You see... JdB said, mainly not only ! No problem if they are posted in the CP Thread aswell but not every visitor looks through the CP thread. If I'd look for info about the Bushwars Mod, my first thought would be to check out the dedicated mod thread. -------------------- |
|
|
Jul 23 2008, 12:54
Post
#277
|
|
N00b always & everywhere Group: Members Posts: 430 Joined: 30-October 07 From: Wodzisław Śl. - Poland Member No.: 1,589 |
Yea, here you are right.
|
|
|
Jul 27 2008, 04:01
Post
#278
|
|
ArmA.info Sarcasm Society's Mr. Argentina 2012 Group: Newshound Posts: 498 Joined: 20-October 07 From: Argentina Member No.: 1,502 |
QUOTE Benoist, firstly: your comment is best placed here where it actually contributes something to the topic as aposed to here. Secondly, not all newsposters have the time to monitor the BI forums 60/60/24/7 as you seem to be expecting of them due to other comitments in real life, for example I have 2 jobs which take up almost every hour I am awake leaving little time for finding and posting news around actually having a life. Anyway, unless you have something to actually say about the news item don't comment. |
|
|
Jul 27 2008, 10:02
Post
#279
|
|
Gentleman Usher of the Coffee Stain Group: Site Team Posts: 677 Joined: 5-November 06 From: C18.3#C77.2#G63.1 Member No.: 19 |
Now that's a rather useless one smiley reply. What do you wanna adress us with?
-------------------- |
|
|
Jul 27 2008, 10:38
Post
#280
|
|
Hipster addonmaker Group: Former .info Serviceman Posts: 2,090 Joined: 1-November 06 From: Kingdom of the Netherlands Member No.: 10 |
Now that's a rather useless one smiley reply. What do you wanna adress us with? Furthermore, where was it posted? (I searched, but couldn't find it) Who posted it? A link to the topic could have been useful, smiley-only replies are not useful, they're considered spam, and so even more moderating actions are required: QUOTE [§5] No Spam
We deem spam as making a thread or posting a reply that has no real worth, is irrelevant, useless and offers nothing to a discussion, that is posted outside the Chatter, Word Games & Jokes sub-forum of the forum's which has its own rules stickied in the sub-forum. Posts that are in place of a moderator and are misleading or not needed, or that are not in line with the topic and contribute nothing of any worth can also be considered spam. Responding to a spam-bot on the forum will be considered spam and will lead to a post restriction. Spam is not limited to text, posting an image as a means of spam or a spam'esque URL will also result in the same response from a moderator. With spam being hard to define, it is another example of something left to moderator's discretion, if in doubt ask yourself "does my reply add to the discussion in a way for the discussion to continue further"? If not then think of something "meatier" to add to the thread. Repeated spamming will result in a Warning Level increase. -------------------- |
|
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 26th April 2024 - 19:12 |